While Fitzgerald favored titling the novel "Trimalchio" , we discussed the differences between this character of classic literature and Gatsby. As Nina noted, Trimalchio is a crass pretentious boor while Gatsby is a tragic idealist . I then explored the contrasting symbols of the green light and the Valley of Ashes, and we discussed the novel in terms of these symbols specifically whether the green light of Gatsby's hopes is totally obscured by the ashes and corruption that surrounds him. We further noted how Gatsby and Mr Wilson, both aptly die at the novel's conclusion having lost their love to same man, the elite and careless Tom Buchanan . In reviewing Nina's study guide answers, we last addressed the interesting reoccurrence of the watchful but unmoving God -like eyes of Dr Ecklberg and inquired into any religious tones the novel may generate as well as the significance of Nick's final remark to Gatsby that "they are a rotten crowd .You're worth more than the rest of them put together." As we conclude our study over the next days, we will consider whether Gatsby is indeed Great as the title pronounces.