For the second hour today, we watched a National Geographic video on black holes. As with the other time we watched a documentary, we stopped frequently so Jared could ask questions, which he did. The documentary mainly dealt with supermassive black holes (those that reside in the centers of galaxies), but the beauty of black holes is that – apart from the slope of the gravitational potential well – they 'behave' in the same way, regardless of if they're the monster black holes at the centers of galaxies or stellar remnants left behind after a supernova explosion.
Assignment
(See previous lesson)
Session Minutes
60
Minutes Student Attended
60
Lesson Comments
Jared was a little bit restless today – I think it had to do with the fact that most of his friends did not have school today. Nevertheless, he made a valiant effort of staying focused – and we did have a double lesson! Even so, he still asked incredibly pointed and relevant questions, especially during the documentary.
We reviewed the evolution of stars much more massive than the Sun, from the point when they've consumed all their fuel. The 'onion ring' model shows us that all elements heavier than hydrogen and helium were produced in nuclear processes inside massive stars. When the star becomes unstable due to the cessation of fusion, the massive envelope collapses onto the iron core. Two things happen next: the intense gravitational field compresses the core even further, so it becomes either a neutron star or a black hole, depending on the initial mass of the star, and the outer envelope slams onto the core and then back into space, creating a supernova explosion.
Assignment
Review the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram: draw it, sketch onto it the evolutionary path of a star like our Sun; what are the endpoints of stars a) like our Sun, b) much heavier than our Sun
We began, as we always do, with a brief review of the previous lesson, so I can test Jared's understanding of the topic. Considering we had a long break, and Jared had two lessons last time, I was impressed with how much he had retained and understood. I went into a bit more depth on the topic of white dwarfs, and then we transitioned to studying the deaths of stars much more massive than the Sun. They follow the same path from birth in a molecular cloud to the main sequence, but thereafter there are differences, most notably, more massive stars consume their fuel faster than stars like our Sun, and, due to their higher gravity, they can initiate carbon fusion in their cores. All the elements up to iron are thus produced. When a massive star has consumed all its fuel, it undergoes a catastrophic explosion that we call a 'supernova'.
Assignment
Finish the questions from last week; added one more question regarding supernovae
Session Minutes
60
Minutes Student Attended
60
Lesson Comments
Jared's understanding of the topic that we covered on Thursday was very good, and he had retained a lot of information. However, I am noticing that he does tend to wiggle out of producing written homework, even though it appears that he is interested in the subject and has even looked up most of the information. I will try to make a more concerted effort of giving him homework in a more formal setting.
In today's second lesson, we continued with the fate of stars like our Sun. Once the star becomes unstable and loses its outer layers after the red giant phase, what's left behind is a very dense object known as a white dwarf. White dwarfs are only about the size of our Earth, but matter is packed in so densely that one spoonful of 'white dwarf matter' weighs as much an elephant. Matter is no longer in the form that we are used to here on Earth, and we need to invoke the Pauli Exclusion Principle to understand how the atoms are packed in so tight. We again covered a lot of material, and even if Jared had to sit through two hours of class today, he remained attentive and inquisitive right until the end.
Assignment
Find the answers to the questions brought up in class, e.g. how long does it take for a star to become a red giant
Session Minutes
60
Minutes Student Attended
60
Lesson Comments
We again covered a lot of material, and even if Jared had to sit through two hours of class today, he remained attentive and inquisitive right until the end. I'm starting to be a little stricter with Jared regarding his homework, and instead of resisting it, he himself is already writing down the questions that he has to research for homework before I even get to tell him, 'Write that down" !
In the first of today's lessons, I started by quizzing Jared on what he had learned the day before regarding the structure of atoms, and how our understanding has progressed. We then reviewed the first stages of a star's life (birth in a molecular cloud, the fusion of hydrogen into helium for about 10 billion years for a star like our Sun). At the end stages, when the star has consumed all its fuel, it becomes unstable and puffs out into what we call a red giant. In 5 billion years, when our Sun will become a red giant, it will encompass Earth's orbit. Following this period, the outer layers of the star will vent into space, and the star enters the stage we call a planetary nebula. We looked at some images of different planetary nebulae, and discussed how the elements formed in the fusion processes inside stars are now contributing to the interstellar medium.
In order to understand the full importance of the fusion processes inside stars, and what role they play in the life cycle of the stars, we need to understand the fundamentals of the elements. So today we studied the periodic table and discussed how the order of the elements in the table is related to the number of protons in the nucleus. We also revisited the basic principles of the structure of the atom, and we touched upon the strong nuclear force.
Assignment
Describe in a few sentences the history of the discovery of the atom, from Democritus ('uncuttable' model), through Rutherford's, Bohr's, Thomson's models, concluding with our understanding today
Session Minutes
60
Minutes Student Attended
60
Lesson Comments
We covered a very complex topic today, but Jared told me that in fact today's lesson explained a lot of what we went through yesterday. Through his questions and comments during the class, it did indeed appear that he has started grasping the ideas covered.
Main sequence stars; the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram
Lesson Outline
Today we moved on to the structure and evolution of stars. We discussed the fusion processes inside stars like the Sun, and I explained how the radiation pressure resulting from fusion (hydrogen into helium, primarily) counteracts the gravitational pressure, and so we have a perfect sphere in equilibrium. Stars spend the majority of their lives (around 90%) on the 'main sequence', after their birth in a gas cloud. A star like the Sun is expected to live around 10 billion years, which is how long it takes for the fuel to run out (once most of the hydrogen has been converted to helium in its core). All stars can categorized according to temperature and luminosity, and when plotted will show a fairly tight correlation on the 'Hertzsprung-Russell diagram'.
Assignment
Learn about the 'tachyon' and report tomorrow
Session Minutes
60
Minutes Student Attended
60
Lesson Comments
Jared appeared a bit tired today - he had been absent yesterday, I understood, so his tiredness might be related to that. Nevertheless, he appeared as interested and curious as ever, and followed in class right to the last minute, even if we dealt with some complex topics!
I began by quizzing Jared on eclipses (his homework for the previous day had been to study the mechanics of eclipses). Jared appears to be very interested in eclipses, and considering a partial eclipse was scheduled for the early evening of Thursday, I thought it would be a good opportunity to examine the topic closely. We then moved onto star charts, and discussed the different types of objects represented in star charts. I also quizzed Jared on his understanding of the different objects.
Assignment
Study the star chart; take the binoculars and look at the night sky first by naked eye, then with the binoculars. Make a note of what you see.
Session Minutes
60
Minutes Student Attended
60
Lesson Comments
I quizzed Jared - verbally - during this lesson twice, and he really seems to retain information from previous lessons very well. I will graduate soon to presenting him with more written assignments/quizzes.
We started class with Jared telling me what he had learned last night reading about constellations. He had researched the topic well, and was very eager to share what had struck him. He remarked upon the fact that most of the constellations appeared to have Roman and Greek names, and so we reviewed the genesis of modern astronomy in Greek and Roman times. We also discussed the legacy of the early Egyptian astronomers, in that the individual stars in the constellations are still known by their Arabic names today. We used star charts to study the constellations, and we started looking at stellar brightnesses. At the end of the lesson, it was Jared who reminded me that there will be a partial solar eclipse tomorrow!
Assignment
Write down the important details regarding tomorrow's solar eclipse, including viewing possibilities from South Florida
Session Minutes
60
Minutes Student Attended
60
Lesson Comments
Another good class. Jared was so excited about what he had learned regarding the constellations, he didn't even wait for me to start the class, he eagerly started telling me what he had read. He was attentive throughout the class, and appeared intrigued that there were such things as star charts in books and the like. He was most interested when we compared real photos of the night sky with their representations in star charts.
We started discussing the birth of the stars by reviewing the processes that occur in gas/molecular clouds - clumps of gas condense and through gravitation and friction the gas ignites and a star is born (when enough mass has accumulated). We also started looking at star charts, for we will use them in future lessons when discussing stellar magnitudes. In so doing, we touched again upon ancient civilizations that first charted the skies, and thus understood the cyclical nature of 'time'.
Assignment
Read the Wikipedia entry on constellations; we will discuss in class tomorrow
Session Minutes
60
Minutes Student Attended
60
Lesson Comments
Again, the interest is there, the right questions are asked. I had noticed that Jared sometimes doesn't follow my instructions for homework, but we always have a good discussion in class and it's obvious he has researched the topic. After a chat with Judie today, I will start preparing questions in written format for Jared's homework, and start asking for longer, more comprehensive written answers.